Water and Astrobiology
The Universe is full of life but it always needs water to initiate and evolve.
Water on Earth
Water and life
The origin of Earth's water
What is life?
How life originated
How many planets have life in the Universe
Life on Mars
It is unnatural in a large field to have only one stalk of wheat.
and in the infinite universe only one living world
Astrobiology is the study of the origin and evolution of life on Earth and its expectation and possibilities throughout the Universe
The age of Universe is thought to be about 13.8 Ga (from the 'Big Bang'), with our galaxy (the Milky Way) 13.6 Ga, the Sun 4.6 Ga and our solar system 4.57 Ga. The Earth is about 4.54 Ga but at 4.5 Ga it was hit by a Mars-sized hypothetical planet (Theia) that blasted out an enormous amount of debris that formed the Moon. Any life that started before this massive collision would have been lost with new life originating and evolving later. Many stars had formed before our sun and it is likely that life has originated (and perhaps been lost) many times, throughout the Universe and before us, as many planets are found around other stars.
In space there is not a perfect vacuum. Water is found throughout the Universe mostly as free molecules and amorphous ice. Its spectroscopy may be viewed by orbiting telescopes with our atmosphere blocking most spectroscopy using land-based telescopes. The astrochemistry of water has been reviewed . At temperatures below 180 K water is a stable solid. At pressures below about a 10-9 Pa (such as on the Moon) solid ice would be the stable phase (i.e. it will not sublime) below 124 K. Gaseous and sublimed water will tend to attach itself to mineral surfaces rather than escaping as a gas, which will stabilize it somewhat from sublimation. Of crucial importance for a habitable planet is the presence of liquid water, necessitating an atmosphere and the required temperature range. For life to start there must also be organic matter, either made locally or delivered from space.
In our solar system, the evolution of giant planets supported the existence of a habitable Earth by scattering water-rich planetesimals into the inner Solar System allowing accretion by the Earth, and by orbiting away from the Earth without great eccentricity. Thus the Earth remained in a stable orbit with a stable climate .
[Back to Top ]
The origin of Earth's water
Hydrogen was the first element to be produced (~105 yr) after the 'Big Bang'. Much later (~108 yr) carbon and oxygen were made by fusion reactions inside stars. Hydrogen, helium and oxygen remain the three most common elements in the Universe. It is no surprise that hydrogen and water molecules are the two commonest molecules in the Universe with water occurring in interstellar space, on planets and asteroids and within the atmospheres of stars like our Sun. Water is the commonest molecule on the surface of planet Earth.
The Earth contains about 1% w/w water, but only about 2% of this (~1018m3) makes up our surface oceans, seas, lakes, rivers, clouds and part of our air, the rest being hidden in Earth's mantle and core. This water in the hydrosphere and atmosphere has allowed life to develop but there has been much and continuing debate over how it arrived on our planet .
The likely possibilities are
a) It was there when planet Earth formed, ~4.54 ˣ 109 years ago (4.54 Ga), mostly accumulated from the cloud of dust surrounding the young sun.
b) It arrived soon afterwards from an accumulation of water-containing rocky asteroids, ~4.5 ˣ 109 years ago (4.5 Ga)
c) It arrived somewhat later from icy comets, ~4 ˣ 109 years ago (4 Ga)
Certainly, most of the water was present by ~3.8 ˣ 109 years ago (3.8 Ga), when signs of planetary life have been found. The source of the water has been attributed on the basis of the known isotopic ratio (D/H) of water found on Earth and Moon , and the analyzed comets and asteroids . If the ratios have not been altered by isotopic fractionation over the many years then the most likely source is water-containing rocky asteroids arriving mostly as the planet was formed and soon afterwards [1015, 2172, 2173]. It is now thought that nascent planetary systems may all have the same water resources that we did ; water that was formed before our Sun was born. Therefore, life is likely to be widely established throughout the Universe.
[Back to Top ]
What is life?
Although many have tried, there is no simple definition of life . In the beginning, 'life' entailed little of what is required today within our complex ecology; just a coating to separate it from the outside world, a basic metabolism involving energy input and output, growth and self-replication as there was not the competition for resources. After a very slow beginning over hundreds of millions of years, competition with later-formed living beings and the necessity of new adaptations gave rise to the evolution of early life forms similar to those we have more recently. Life on Earth today is highly competitive and must show most of the following; reproduction, organization, metabolism, non-equilibrium thermodynamics, growth, protection and adaptation. This will require the presence of a liquid to allow ease of molecular interactions and for reactions to proceed. We now know that life requires a flow of energy within an aqueous environment  (see also 'Water and life'). Life is truly remarkable and although we understand (in outline) how it continues, we still do not know how it started.
The periodic table restricts the elements available for life with carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and hydrogen being the four commonest reactive elements in the Universe. Carbon would seem to be the most important as it can produce an enormous range of compounds (organic chemistry). Other elements such as sulfur and silicon cannot form the complexity of molecules necessary for life, Silicon, in particular, tends to form stable silicates. Life on Earth contains these plus many other commonly found elements. All these elements (except hydrogen) are created inside stars and, if common, will form simple compounds in space, with dust particles in space containing up to 35% organic carbon. For forming part of life, molecules need to be relatively easy both to form and to break down and to be relatively stable within a liquid environment.
A stable liquid medium is required, such as water , with other candidate liquids such as N2, H2S, NH3 a and glassy silica being liquid only at low temperatures giving slow reaction rates, or at high temperatures that are destructive and too viscous. Also many of theses putative media freeze from the bottom up that would tend to prevent the establishment of life.
Water is an excellent solvent for salts and polar molecules plus it has an enormous cosmic abundance, a high enthalpy of vaporization, a wide area of liquidity and a high dielectric constant; all important attributes. Mobile water is necessary for the persistence of life. Such water is freely available in liquid water. However where liquid water does not exist, such as on Mars, sufficiently mobile water is still available from the amorphous surfaces of ice crystals and the so-called ‘bound’ water at interfaces with potential organic molecules and inorganic salts and surfaces. Water in the crystalline ice lattice will not be directly available. Exobiological life that evolves from a liquid water rich environment to one that is water poor due to climatic change would need to utilize mechanisms for holding on to its precious mobile water. Such mechanisms are likely to involve highly hydrophilic molecules, both to prevent water escaping and to garner water molecules from the environment.
[Back to Top ]
How life originated
Some microbial life can continue, if slowly, under extreme conditions on Earth, such as several kilometers underground (e.g. the cryptoendoliths, see below) or at -20 °C, or 35 km above ground. Their survival without growth is possible in liquid N2 (77 K), and dry bacterial spores have been shown to survive temperatures down to10 K (outer space). Life may have developed (and died) around stars that no longer exist. Life could therefore have spread around the Universe (panspermia). Microbial life from space would generally have difficulty establishing itself on a planet with well -evolved life forms but might easily establish itself on a planet with metabolizable substrates but no native life-forms. In any case the origin(s) of life still presents a puzzle.
With cool water being available on a crusted Earth by 4.1 Ga, life probably originated on Earth about 4.0 Ga, but there is no record as no sedimentary rocks exist from that time. How life arose on Earth is unknown, maybe from Mars (see below). b How life arose anywhere is unknown. Certainly, the conditions on the early Earth would have been very hostile for most organisms that are around today, with an evolving but reducing atmosphere . This was dominated by carbon dioxide but with evolving amounts of ammonia, nitrogen, hydrogen, carbon monoxide, water vapor, sulfur dioxide, methane and hydrogen sulfide but always very little oxygen. First a chemical soup would be formed in warm water, by reactions from simpler precursors, e.g. hydrogen, methane, formaldehyde, carbon dioxide, ammonia and phosphate. Liquid water is an excellent medium for the formation of such inorganic and organic materials in the presence of ultraviolet light and/or lightning.
The Miller-Urey experimental set-up has been used to synthesize amino acids and nucleic bases, such as alanine (CH3 CHNH3+CO2- ) (see right ; for synthetic routes see ). Similar molecules have been found in Mercury's polar ice.
Also, water ice can act as a substrate and irradiated reactant within interstellar clouds of gas and dust, enabling the formation of key inorganic materials, such as HCN, and organic compounds, such as the carbon hydrates methanal (formaldehyde, H2C=O ), ethanoic acid (acetic acid, CH3CO2H), methyl methanoate (methylformate, CH3OCOCH) and 2-hydroxyacetaldehyde (glycoladehyde , HO-CH2-CH=O), that are important precursors to life. These may have eventually formed part of comets and asteroids in the early Solar System . Additional organics still fall to Earth from space from meteorites and micrometeorite particles (0.02 - 0.4 mm) that currently bring 50,000,000 kg of material, containing organic carbon, to the Earth each year; intact as most float down. Much more would be expected to have fallen in the far past.
It has been shown that precursors of ribonucleotides, amino acids and lipids can all be produced from hydrogen cyanide via simple organics and molecules such as glyceraldehyde . All cellular subsystems could therefore have arisen simultaneously through a common chemistry, with key reaction steps driven by ultraviolet light and using hydrogen sulfide or molecular hydrogen as reductant. The early high concentrations of hydrogen gas would have led to easier syntheses and greater stabilities than are now possible within our more hostile oxidizing environment. Early life would probably have contained the more robust molecules only. Although such reactions would benefit from catalysts, and such catalysts (such as Cu(I)–Cu(II) photo redox cycling , or the Fe(II)–Fe(III) cycle mentioned below) are feasibly present, long lag periods are available on the early Earth for these materials to be formed in quantity without great catalysis.
In the absence of microbial life, pools of organic materials would concentrate and become more complex, perhaps in hydrothermal pores . One of the first key molecules must have been the autocatalyst that could reproduce itself. So long as degradative catalysts were not prevalent, these could be inorganic, such as polyphosphates, or similar to still-extant autocatalysts RNA or protein. This is likely to have been a slowly evolving process of improving autocatalysts. The accepted most probable route would be through RNA-like molecules.
The earliest known life forms were thermophiles that could survive the more frequent violent impacts by large solar system debris before 3.8 Ga with the oldest fossil microorganisms found in Greenland (in 1-4 cm high microbial communities; stromatolites .) dated back to about 3.7 Ga.. Such organisms would have to survive in an anoxic atmosphere until 2.4 Ga, most likely making use of sulfur and iron chemistry .
Likely places for this to happen are hydrothermal vents, either underwater or above sea level. If submarine, they can form 'black smokers' (see left) and 'white smokers', usually surrounded by a rich ecology. Above sea level they are hydrothermal impact crater lakes  or volcanic fumeroles (see above right). In both cases there is a constant supply of warmth (important as there was a much weaker sun than we have today), water and nutrient, but if above sea level there is the addition of the atmosphere, extensive gas-liquid interfaces, sunlight and associated photochemistry, and a restriction in the distribution and loss of products in the vastness of the early oceans. Such fumeroles today show a richer diversity of life forms than other niches even high in the Atacama dessert, one of the most inhospitable places on Earth . Life starting in the early abundance of fumeroles could spread easily through rivers to the oceans.
Water seems to be key to the origin of life. It has the ability to order molecules using its structure, the structure of its ices and the structure of the interfaces between liquid water with solids and gasses. Possibly, following the initial formation of methane (from H2 and CO2) clathrate hydrates under pressure, reactions within the clathrate shells with phosphate and nitrate form ribonucleic acids as the catalysts and blueprint for life .
Certainly, once life is initiated, it has continued to be water based, with even land animals starting within aqueous environments such as eggs.
One of the features of life on Earth is the predominance of certain chiral isomers, such as the L-amino acids and D-sugars. Chirality initially seems surprising if it arose from simple chemical reactions that usually produce equal amounts of the left and right handed chiral products if not in contact with previously chiral material. Water clusters are often chiral but there are equal numbers of right and left-handed forms . It now seems likely that chiral products can be produced in a system solely driven by auto catalysis to reach global homochirality . Surprisingly, there is an excess of D-sugar derivatives such as D-gluconic acid (over the L forms) in carbonaceous meteorites that are the same age as the solar system (4.5 Ga) . The reason for the excess is undetermined but it has been suggested that circularly polarized light during synthesis may be the cause.
One way to attempt to discover the earliest organisms on Earth is to look within extant organisms for common ancestors of all life. After examining 286,000 gene families the last universal common ancestor (LUCA) was found likely to have been a thermophilic, anaerobic, N2-fixing single-celled organism that lived in an oxygen-free hot spring. It fixed CO2 using H2 as an electron donor ; with outline metabolism (Wood-Ljungdahl pathway) resulting in acetyl-coenzyme A:
CO2 + H2 CO + H2O
CO2 + 3H2 + H-R +energy H3C-R + 2H2O
H3C-R + CO H3CCO~R biomass
This LUCA is already highly sophisticated, involving the central dogma of information flow in known life (DNA RNA proteins) and must have been preceded by at least two hundred million years of a wonderfully complex and, as yet, unknown evolutionary process probably involving many false starts.
The diagram below shows what has happened during Earth's existence with biological events and geological periods. Note the extensive period that prokaryotes have been around (>1011 generations, compared with just 104 generations for modern man). The two million year Quaternary period, the time of recognizable human ancestors, is too small to be visible at this scale. The 195,000 years of Homo Sapiens (that is, us) would be represented by under a tenth of a pixel in this diagram.
[Back to Top ]
How many planets with life in the Universe?
Although there is some dispute, the universe is thought to be about 93 billion light years across and contains something like 1011 to 1012 stars in our Galaxy, and there are perhaps something like 2 ˣ 1012 galaxies. with each star having on average one planet. Therefore there are about 1023 to 1024 planets. However, many of these will not be in their system's habitable zone .
A planet in the habitable zone has no guarantee of actually being habitable. Venus and Earth are both within the Sun’s habitable zone and would appear from current exoplanet discovery techniques to be the same size and mass. Yet, Venus is completely hostile to life owing to its high surface temperatures (462 °C), whereas Earth has the right surface temperature for liquid water with oceans teeming with life. The habitable zone could exist from about 0.5 AU out to about 5 AU (would include Venus, Earth, Mars and Jupiter in the solar system) for a solar-type star, or even beyond, depending on the planet’s interior, its mass and its atmospheric characteristics. THe existence of liquid water is probably insufficient, in itself, for life, with very deep water-covered planets being unsuitable due to loss of material to high pressure ice environments at depth and so restricting life . As such, there is no universal habitable zone applicable to all exoplanets. In all likelihood, about 1 in 100 planets would be both within the zone, and suitable for life. That still gives at least 1020 planets suitable for life in the Universe.
Some argue that, although microbial-like life may be much more common, life as complex as that on Earth is extremely rare in the universe as, in our case, it seems to require an exceptionally unlikely set of circumstances involving having a large moon, plate tectonics, a magnetic field and a gas giant like Jupiter for protection and an orbit in the habitable zone of the right kind of star . However, these restrictions seem too great  as our Sun is a common star type (G-type main-sequence star that fuses hydrogen to helium for about 10 billion years, also known as a yellow dwarf, ~10% of known stars), Jupiter-sized planets seem common at about the same position, a large moon may not be necessary and there are many other uncertainties. Even if only one suitable planet existed per galaxy, there would still be a hundred billion of suitable planets.
[Back to Top ]
Putative life on Mars
The possibility of life on Mars  was mooted after the Allan Hills 1.93 kg meteorite (ALH84001, found in Allan Hills, Antarctica in 1984, see right) was reported to possibly contain evidence for microscopic fossils of Martian bacteria based on the carbonate globules observed (see below left).
This meteorite had formed about 4 Ga but had been blasted off from the surface of Mars by a meteoritic impact about 17 million years ago and fell roughly 13,000 years ago  onto the Antarctic's protective environment. Thousands of other martian meteorites have landed on Earth, but this is the oldest known. The rock had many 300-micron-wide carbonate globules that must have formed in water. The tubular structure (see left) is thought by some to be the remains of a biofilm with its associated microbial community, but others have since been expressed doubts  .
It appears that suitable conditions were available on Mars up to about 4 Ga when Mars appears to have had sufficient ground water and atmosphere for life to evolve. However the conditions on Mars have been much more demanding over the last billion years or so, with the loss of much of the atmosphere, prevalence of much colder conditions and the apparent disappearance of much of the water. However, pictures from the Phoenix Mars Lander (b, right) show ground conditions similar to those in permafrost regions of Earth where life still flourishes (a, right). Although it seems highly unlikely that life currently exists on Mars, it is possible to hypothesize life forms that could have adapted to these conditions.
The distribution of water in the ground surface has been determined in this false-color map of Mars (below), where deep blue indicates the presence of water or ice deposits. Most of this water resides at the poles. Mars, today, is a frozen desert with only about 10 ml of precipitable water per square meter of surface. The atmospheric water vapor content averages only about 0.1 Pa at 220 K, with this water coming from sublimation of the polar ice caps.
Water is presently associated with minerals or as sub-surface deposits, with occasional flows of liquid water on the surface  and the formation of night-time transient liquid brines in the uppermost 5 cm of the subsurface that then evaporates after sunrise  .
The biggest problem to be overcome by life on Mars is that of collecting and retaining the water necessary for life. Whatever metabolism is envisaged, mobile water is necessary to ease molecular mechanisms.
This water must be acquired from the atmosphere and held locally, overcoming the low vapor pressure present. Organisms must then be able to access this water, utilize it as a mobile liquid and keep hold of it against adverse changes in conditions and, perhaps, substitute for it during periods of more extreme drought during such periods of dormancy as are required. There are several ways by which water can be held against extremely low vapor pressures. For example, by controlling pH, water can be held strongly by some salts for later use (e.g. Al(OH)3, see above right).
Liquid water can also be held strongly by osmotic pressure, as is utilized using super-absorbent cross-linked polyacrylate (see left) in disposable nappies. During periods of extremely low water availability, living organisms on Earth replace some of their water by organic alcohols, such as α, α,-trehalose.
On Mars, life forms would also be expected to make use of this process, perhaps for very extensive periods. During such periods the life forms would lie dormant as biological processes cannot continue, except perhaps at an extremely slow rate.
Mobile liquid water is required for the continuance of life. Such water can exist far below the freezing point of pure water due to capillarity, pressure or colligative freezing point depression effects lowering the water activity. When materials dissolve in water, the freezing point decreases in line with the mole fraction of water. Thus free liquid water may be available down to -50 °C (see right) so long as there is sufficient solute available. If the temperature is higher, then less solute is required.
Life on Earth can persist even in very cold and dry Antarctic deserts. These harsh conditions, however, present easier conditions for life than found on Mars.
Life on Mars must be surrounded by a sheath that achieves two aims, attracting and binding scarce water and protecting against Mars's prevalent ultraviolet radiation. It is likely that it would consist of layers, with the outer layers binding the water most strongly and the inner (life) layer allowing some aqueous mobility.
Therefore, life on Mars, if extant, is likely to show similarities to some of Earth’s microorganisms, such as the cryptoendoliths that survive as extremophile microbial communities. On Earth, these are a combination of fungi and algae that grow inside clear rock just a few millimeters under the surface (see cross-section right). They are able to shut down metabolically and individual organisms are capable of surviving hundreds of years of intense cold, and drought. An outer iron mineral layer could offer protection from UV light.
Martian life could have evolved several billion years ago when conditions were much kinder, but today such life has to survive within an anaerobic, water sparse, ultraviolet lit and extremely cold environment. A possible metabolic mechanism is given left, where the energetic input comes from the UV, causing the separation of electrons and positive ‘holes’ in hematite. Such a metabolism utilizes methane, the gas that is currently sought by the joint European/ Russian ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO), that lifted off from Baikonur in Kazakhstan on 14 March 2016.
On the basis of this scenario, life forms on Mars would be expected to have an important one-carbon metabolism. On Earth such metabolism makes use of a cobalt-containing coenzyme, so it may be fruitful to look for pockets of cobalt concentrations within the surface rocks of Mars.
[Back to Top ]
a Biological catalysis of reactions substantially increases reaction rates, and at extremely high pressures ammonia could remain in liquid state up to its critical temperature of 132 °C. [Back]
b It seems likely that, if microbial-like life was brought to Earth from space then there may well be such life in all the suitable niches within the solar system, such as Saturn's moon Enceladus that has liquid water. [Back]